Talk:Project Guidelines

From OpenFOAMWiki

Contents

Thread titleRepliesLast modified
Discussions on unresolved topics112:53, 29 March 2014
Github/Bitpucket pull-request112:44, 29 March 2014

Discussions on unresolved topics

I think it would be best to first discuss new topics here before adding them to the main page (especially if you don't agree with something people say there or if you're offering alternatives - like the Github or Bitbucket-entry). That way it can be avoided that large chunks of text will be afterwards "edited away". Which for some people will look like censorship

Bgschaid (talk)03:34, 28 March 2014

I personally don't mind that my proposal get's scratched away from the main page at all - the page then can serve as a proposal summary (not get burried in a discussion) and then removed later if people are against it. but I definitely agree with you on this, others may feel differently about this.

Tomislav Maric (talk)12:53, 29 March 2014
 

Github/Bitpucket pull-request

I believe recently Sourceforg added a "Fork"-button to git and mercurial-repositories. Haven't tried it yet, but I think this would allow something similar inside the existing infrastructure

Bgschaid (talk)03:30, 28 March 2014

What I really like about the pull request system of github is that zero work is included in organizing teams in transparent way (same goes for bitbucket), and the code review process is fully open and easily done by a lot of people at once - this is what both sites specialize in. I don't want to be the stupid new guy that pushes new things (although I am playing that role very well for now :)), but I really do believe that using those services would make it easier for newcomers to get involved. I've used bitbucket for collaborative work and the part of the web interface that deals with collaboration is way more clear and way more powerful than the one on sourceforge. And since the project is based on git, moving it to github / bitbucket should take like 10 minutes, right?

Tomislav Maric (talk)12:44, 29 March 2014